| The Rev. Dr. Theodore F. Clark |
1907 - 1908 |
| The Rev. Dr. William E. Lawrence |
1908 - 1911 |
| The Rev. Claude C. Coyle |
1911 - 1916 |
| The Rev. William D. Carnes |
1916 - 1919 |
| The Rev. John J. Fourst |
1919 - 1922 |
| The Rev. Rowland Hill |
1922 - 1925 |
| The Rev. Dr. Elmer A. Dent |
1925 - 1927 |
| The Rev. Paul DuBois |
1927 - 1931 |
| The Rev. Dr. Leland P. Cary |
1931 - 1934 |
| The Rev. Kenneth B. Grady |
1935 - 1942 |
| The Rev. Dr. Ernest Wall |
1942 - 1951 |
| The Rev. Richard A. Thornburg |
1951 - 1953 |
| The Rev. Mulford B. Simonson |
1953 - 1958 |
| The Rev. Eugene H. Haaf |
1958 - 1963 |
| The Rev. Wayne White |
1963 |
| The Rev. Mervin F. Hill |
1964 - 1969 |
| The Rev. Steward S. Oakes |
1969 - 1971 |
| The Rev. George A. Shepherd |
1971 - 1983 |
| The Rev. Kenneth W. Prill |
1983 - 1992 |
| The Rev. Karen A. Burger |
1992 - 1996 |
| The Rev. Grace C. J. Ross |
1996 - 2000 |
| The Rev. Ieva Zadina |
2000 - 2005 |
| The Rev. David T. Ball |
2005 - 2011 |
| The Rev. Dr. Johnny L. Ceasar |
2011 - 2013 |
| The Rev. Dr. Bronco H. Crooke |
2013 - |
